Msnbc: drug testing welfare recipients looks even worse, “ 265 responses to drug testing welfare users is a sham, but not for the reasons you think. What 7 states discovered after spending more than $1 million drug testing welfare recipients what a waste. Drug testing welfare recipients misses the mark susana morris says that testing is a waste of money and perpetuates a long-held myth of what life on welfare looks like. See the opposing argument here when one first hears about the idea of testing welfare recipients to make sure that they are not using drugs, the idea seems to be. Seven states have enacted drug testing for welfare applicants in an effort to cut costs and combat fraud -- but it’s not clear the move does either.
Drug tests would be a massive waste of resources and would stigmatize the poor. But the republican solution — to tie federal assistance to drug testing — is more than just silly it runs contrary to everything conservatives are. When wisconsin gov scott walker announced his presidential candidacy, he made one of his priorities very clear: he wanted welfare recipients to pass a. Gov asa hutchinson defended statewide testing of certain welfare recipients last week as a blow at drug dependence, not merely a punish-the-poor policy to mollify.
I read on facebook that a new law in florida requires welfare recipients to get drug tests and, as a result, thousands of welfare recipients have left the. Courts agree: blanket drug testing with no individualized reason for suspicion is unconstitutional but politicians and other leaders continue to try to implement. The results from drug testing welfare recipients and applicants are in — and they might surprise you. States already do a good job of ensuring no one gets a free ride we don't need another one--especially one that stimgatizes.
Tallahassee since the state began testing welfare applicants for drugs in july, about 2 percent have tested positive, preliminary data shows. 5 reasons drug testing welfare recipients is profoundly stupid drug testing people who need government assistance hits every mark of extraordinarily bad policy. Drug testing welfare recipients--false positives, false negatives, unanticipated opportunities harold pollack department of health management and policy. The centre for addiction and mental health (camh) does not support mandatory drug testing and treatment for people on welfare research has.
The michigan senate passed a bill wednesday that would require welfare recipients undergo drug testing if welfare recipients refuse to be tested, they would lose. Do you think states should give drug tests to welfare recipients more on aolcom: north carolina releases results of welfare-applicant drug tests.
In the us, drug use is at an overall rate of 94 percent, “in these [seven] states, however, the rate of positive drug tests to total welfare applicants ranges. For a year, michigan tried to find out how many of its welfare recipients were abusing drugs a pilot program’s tally zero only one person in the study. Many states have implemented or discussed plans that require their welfare recipients to pass a drug test in order to be eligible for benefits these policie. A new law requires welfare applicants to take a drug test if they answer yes to any of three questions states consider drug testing welfare recipients. Several states had a theory: mandating drug tests for welfare applicants would save taxpayer money the results have been nothing short of a fiasco.
Wisconsin's welfare overhaul is almost complete the trump administration could soon approve a proposal from governor scott walker to drug test food-stamp recipients. That is despite a 2003 federal court ruling in michigan that struck down drug testing for welfare recipients because it amounted to an illegal search. Drug testing people who need government assistance hits every mark of extraordinarily bad policy before scott walker unhappily shuffled away from the gop primary. A new state law designed to prevent drug users from receiving welfare benefits could end up costing taxpayers far more than it saves, while inadvertently denying. The routine drug testing of welfare recipients is a sticky subject, but it seems as if neither side talks about the most important thing here the left often says it. Michigan has a history of drug testing welfare recipients in 1999, the state implemented a pilot program to randomly test welfare recipients across the state. Should all welfare recipients be drug tested get the facts on both sides of this argument.